On the other hand in Germany it was clear that it was the unification from the above. Compare and contrast the unification of Germany and Italy in the ‘s. Prussia took more or less five years to unify. Auth with social network: Help Center Find new research papers in:

Solid Theses The efforts of Mazzini, Cavour, and others to unify Italy raised debate on how to best do so. Gioberti himself being a priest, would likely advocate for such a method, as his allegiance lies directly with the pope. However, a deep analysis of the historical events shows that small differences occurred in every part of the revolution. This commonness in culture united was the main factor that united the Italians. During Italian unification, debates over whether Italy should be a monarchy or a republic were prominent, and some advocated for the continued separation of Italian states.

Italian Unification DBQ

This conflict between ways of unification went on until Prussia unified all German speaking states except Austria. Published by Silas Davis Modified over 3 years ago. The unifications of Prussia and Italy have many general similarities such as the common enemy and the outside help. The first main similarity between the unification of Germany and Italy is that both abhorred the dominance of Austria in their territories.

Both the two countries were assisted by foreign help in order to unify.


Germany had as main nation-state Prussia. Despite some initial successes, the revolutionary movement failed as revolts were ultimately suppressed by despotic rulers.

Remember me on this computer.

italian unification dbq thesis

Nationalism Nationalism Preview Preview: German confederation was found as a result of Congress of Vienna but it was under control of Austria and as a result many German liberals and patriots acted against Congress of Vienna and dominance of Austria. Resolutions proposed included unification under a monarchy, unification under a republic, and no unification at all.

Zollverein made German people to realize the economic benefits after unification and paved the way for the unity in Germany. German and Italian reunification has similarities and differences. His role as a philosopher may give him a better understanding of human nature, so he is able to see a reason beside a political one, of why Italy cannot unify as it will be challenging for the people.

Since he became more conservative, he would oppose any new form of government or change, which is exactly what he is doing in his statement towards Italy.

He believes that the centuries of Italian separation cannot be helped and that people will be loyal to their states rather than to a unified Italy. In order to complete her unification Italy lost Nice and Savoy which were donated to France for her efforts.


Same in Italy Napoleon sparked nationalism and liberalism. The unifications of Germany and Italy have many similarities as well as differences.

Italian Unification DBQ

Your e-mail Input it if you want to receive answer. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Compare and contrast German and Italian unification.

italian unification dbq thesis

Bismarck In Modern Europe. Political Unififation in the West during the 19th revised. But in Italy there was no such economic union like Zollverein which affected the unification. Skip to main content. German Unification and the Balance of Power. Add this document to saved.

Auth with social network: Prussia took more or less five years to unify. The Crimean war helped them. We think you have liked this presentation. Italy became a Unitarian state while the German nation states maintained their sovereignty as long as they accepted the as emperor the leader of Prussia. He displays his views on the futility of unification efforts by describing them as people building their ideas on sand, which means without a strong base and foundation.

Compare and contrast German and Italian unification.